HOSSTILE SILO[9] EAA + Hydration Powder
- Momentous Vital Aminos★★★★★★★★★★★★3.9 / 6
- Nutrex Research EAA+ Hydration★★★★★★★★★★★★3 / 6
- Nutricost EAA Powder★★★★★★★★★★★★2.5 / 6
PearlQuant ratings on the same 6 criteria as this product (2.5 / 6); tap a name for its rating.
Essential Amino Acids with Electrolytes, EAA BCAA Intra Workout Powder & Post Workout Recovery, Tangy Raspberry, 30 Servings. One serving (1 rounded scoop) mixed with 10 fl. oz. of water, before, during, or after training.
Watch
Our video for this product. Nothing loads from YouTube until you press play.
An amino-acid drink first and a hydration drink second. Every amount is printed: 8,000 mg of the nine essential amino acids per scoop, 3,000 mg of it leucine, a dose that stimulates muscle protein synthesis in trials[1], though three-quarters of the mix is BCAA[2] and the response seems to plateau near 15–18 g[3]. The recovery evidence for BCAA is less soreness and a lower blood marker of muscle damage (creatine kinase), not faster recovery of strength or performance[4], and the regimens that showed it were larger and longer than one scoop[5]. As hydration it is light: 100 mg sodium per scoop is about a tenth of an hour's typical sweat loss[6], and the coconut water is 500 mg of powder[7]. It is sweetened with sucralose, an artificial sweetener (one label version adds acesulfame potassium)[8]. Reasonable as an intra-workout amino drink for lifters who want one; not a substitute for a sodium-forward electrolyte product, or for carbohydrate on long sessions.
References: 1 Wilkinson 2013 PubMed › · 2 Jackman 2017 PubMed › · 3 Ferrando 2023 PubMed › · 4 Doma 2021 PubMed › · 5 Fouré 2017 PubMed › · 6 Baker 2017 PubMed › · 7 Kalman 2012 PubMed › · 8 Ivanova 2026 PubMed ›
SILO[9]'s two jobs from two single products
SILO[9] does two jobs in one scoop: essential amino acids and electrolytes. Each pair below does both jobs with no artificial sweetener, at least SILO[9]'s 8 g of essential amino acids and 3 g of leucine, and five times its sodium.
- 2 scoops of Momentous Vital Aminos, Tropical Punch★★★★★★★★★★★★3.9 / 6One scoop has 5.57 g of essential amino acids and 2.5 g of leucine, so the pick takes two, twice the label's serving.
- 1 scoop of Transparent Labs Hydrate, Tropical Punch★★★★★★★★★★★★5.429 / 6
$3.82 per serving
Every part is listed by NSF Certified for Sport and sweetened only with stevia; it costs about three times as much as SILO[9].
- 1 scoop of Nutricost EAA Powder, Unflavored★★★★★★★★★★★★3.5 / 6Unflavoured, with no sweetener; the label lists about 3 g of leucine (approx. 3,000 mg) inside its 6 g 2:1:1 BCAA blend.
- 1 scoop of Transparent Labs Hydrate, Tropical Punch★★★★★★★★★★★★5.429 / 6
$1.35 per serving
Matches SILO[9]'s amino-acid dose in one scoop for a little more than SILO[9] costs, but the amino-acid powder is not listed by any certifier we searched.
| Per serving | SILO[9] | PearlQuant pick | Lower-cost option |
|---|---|---|---|
| Essential amino acids | 8 g | 11.14 g | 8 g |
| Leucine | 3 g | 5 g | 3 g |
| Sodium | 100 mg | 500 mg | 500 mg |
| Potassium | 200 mg | 250 mg | 250 mg |
| Magnesium | 100 mg | 50 mg | 50 mg |
| Sweetener | Sucralose (the listing also names acesulfame potassium) | Stevia only | None in the amino acids; stevia in the electrolytes |
| Certified in a certifier's database | None found | Both (NSF Certified for Sport) | Electrolytes only (NSF Certified for Sport) |
| Cost per serving | $1.17 | $3.82 | $1.35 |
Not carried over: SILO[9]'s 100 mg of vitamin B5, which its listing claims nothing for. Both pairs have half SILO[9]'s magnesium (50 mg against 100 mg). We have not tested the powders mixed in one bottle. Not medical advice. Amazon one-time prices read 2026-10-13. Tap a product for its PearlQuant rating.
Also considered: Gnarly Essential Aminos (certified and cheaper per dose than Momentous, but its label amounts could not be confirmed); BulkSupplements EAA (certified and the cheapest, but its label hides the leucine amount inside a 10 g blend); Purist Hydration (certified, at the same price as Transparent Labs Hydrate with about the same sodium (510 mg against 500 mg) and a little more magnesium (60 mg against 50 mg); a close alternative we have not rated).
Per serving (1 rounded scoop, 15.5 g) · Supplement Facts
- Calories10
- Total Carbohydrate3 g1% DV
- Pantothenic Acid100 mg2000% DV
- Magnesium (as Trimagnesium Citrate)100 mg24% DV
- Sodium (as Sodium Chloride)100 mg4% DV
- Potassium (as Potassium Chloride)200 mg4% DV
- BCAA 2:1:1 Blend (Fermented)6000 mg
- Instantized L-Leucine3000 mg
- Instantized L-Isoleucine1500 mg
- Instantized L-Valine1500 mg
- L-Threonine1000 mg
- Coconut Fruit Water Powder500 mg
- L-Lysine (as L-Lysine HCl)450 mg
- L-Phenylalanine400 mg
- L-Histidine (Fermented)50 mg
- L-Methionine50 mg
- L-Tryptophan50 mg
The nine essential amino acids add up to 8,000 mg per serving, 6,000 mg of them the three BCAAs; lysine, histidine, methionine and tryptophan are 450, 50, 50 and 50 mg.
- BCAAs6,000 mg75%leucine 3,000 mg · isoleucine 1,500 mg · valine 1,500 mg
- Threonine and phenylalanine1,400 mg17.5%threonine 1,000 mg · phenylalanine 400 mg
- The other four600 mg7.5%lysine 450 mg · histidine 50 mg · methionine 50 mg · tryptophan 50 mg
Of the 8,000 mg, 75% is the three BCAAs, and 3,000 mg of that is leucine, the branched-chain amino acid most studied as the trigger of muscle protein synthesis; 3.42 g of free leucine roughly doubled synthesis for a few hours in young men at rest, against each man's fasted baseline[1]. The 3,000 mg meets the International Society of Sports Nutrition's figure of 700–3,000 mg of leucine per acute protein dose, which the society pairs with a balanced array of the essential amino acids[2]. A review (author with amino-acid industry ties) argues that BCAAs alone cannot sustain synthesis, because the other six essential amino acids must then come from the breakdown of muscle protein[3]. In trained young men, 5.6 g of BCAA alone right after lifting raised myofibrillar protein synthesis 22% over placebo, though the authors conclude BCAA alone does not stimulate it maximally[4]. Here the other six are the smaller share: threonine and phenylalanine add 1,400 mg, and lysine, histidine, methionine and tryptophan share the last 600 mg (450 of it lysine); histidine, methionine and tryptophan are there so the mix is complete on paper, not in amounts that matter on their own. The whole 8 g is about half the 15–18 g at which, the same society's 2023 stand says, synthesis seems to plateau at rest[5].
References: 1 Wilkinson 2013 PubMed › · 2 Jäger 2017 PubMed › · 3 Wolfe 2017 PubMed › · 4 Jackman 2017 PubMed › · 5 Ferrando 2023 PubMed ›
Two versions of the label appear on the listing: the label photo prints magnesium 100 mg and lists sucralose as the only sweetener, with natural flavoring; the listing's ingredient text says magnesium 50 mg, sucralose and acesulfame potassium, and natural and artificial flavor. Check the tub you buy.
Directions: As a dietary supplement, take one serving (1 rounded scoop) of SILO[9], mixed with 10 fl. oz. of water and consume before, during, or after training, or any time throughout the day.
Other ingredients (label photo): Citric Acid, Malic Acid, Maltodextrin, Natural Flavoring, DiSodium Phosphate, Sucralose, Litesse Polydextrose, Red Beet Powder (for Color).
Allergens: Contains: Tree Nuts (coconut). Allergen Warning: This product has been produced in a facility that also processes wheat, soy, eggs, shellfish, sesame, peanuts, tree nuts, and milk.
This product is only intended to be consumed by healthy adults, 18 years of age or older. Do not use if pregnant or nursing. Consult with a licensed, qualified, healthcare professional before taking this or any dietary supplement product, especially if you are taking medication or have a medical condition. Discontinue 2 weeks prior to surgery.
One scoop's 100 mg sodium is a small fraction of typical hourly sweat sodium loss; anyone training long in the heat should not rely on this drink alone for sodium. It supplies 3 g of carbohydrate, so it is not fuel for long sessions.
The 2023 ISSN position stand notes there is insufficient data on people with impaired kidney function to determine the safety of EAA-based supplements; people with kidney disease, or on medicines that raise blood potassium, should ask a clinician before using amino-acid and potassium-containing drinks. Contains 400 mg L-phenylalanine per scoop: not for people with phenylketonuria. The amount of sucralose (and, in one label version, acesulfame potassium) is not disclosed.
Statements regarding dietary supplements have not been evaluated by the FDA and are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease or health condition.
Not medical advice.
Amounts from the Supplement Facts panel in the listing's label images (Tangy Raspberry, 30 servings); names, directions, ingredients and cautions from the Amazon listing, read 2026-10-05; check the tub you buy.
100 mg per scoop (24% DV) on the Supplement Facts panel; the listing's ingredient text says 50 mgMagnesium (as Trimagnesium Citrate)
Trimagnesium dicitrate is the fully neutralized salt of three magnesium ions with two citrate ions (C12H10Mg3O14, molecular weight 451; PubChem CID 6099959), about 16% magnesium by weight. The label counts elemental magnesium: 100 mg of it is roughly 620 mg of the salt, about 4% of the scoop. It is a water-soluble form; the oxide form sold in many tablets is not.
Why it is here: The listing groups magnesium with sodium and potassium as the electrolyte part of an ‘EAA + Hydration’ powder and says the three ‘support hydration and replenish electrolytes lost in sweat’; it makes no magnesium-specific claim.
- Normal volunteers given a single 25 mmol (about 608 mg) oral load: magnesium citrate raised 4-hour urinary magnesium far more than magnesium oxide (0.22 vs 0.006 mg per mg creatinine, p<0.05, within-subject). Citrate was 55% soluble in water; oxide was virtually insoluble. About six times this scoop's dose. PubMed ›
- 46 healthy adults took 300 mg magnesium a day for 60 days as citrate, amino-acid chelate, oxide or placebo (randomized, double-blind): citrate and the chelate, pooled, gave higher 24-hour urinary magnesium than oxide at 60 days (P=0.033; after outlier adjustment per a 2025 extraction of the full text, with no differences after a single dose) and citrate the greatest serum magnesium (P=0.006). The chelate was not separated from citrate on absorption and sat below it on serum; oxide did not differ from placebo. Three times this scoop's dose; the magnesium-forms card below has the detail. PubMed ›
- Systematic review of 14 randomized trials in healthy adults (100–866 mg/day; part-funded by K+S, a mineral-salt producer): magnesium citrate and chloride well absorbed, magnesium oxide poorly, attributed partly to oxide's poor solubility; most trials were small crossovers. PubMed ›
- 16 healthy volunteers taking about 255 mg magnesium a day: oxide showed 4% fractional absorption while chloride, lactate and aspartate were higher and equal to each other (within-subject). Citrate was not tested; a soluble inorganic salt matched the organic ones, so solubility rather than an ‘organic’ label explains the differences. PubMed ›
- A 2017 review of magnesium bioavailability concludes that ‘the type of Mg2+ salt appears less relevant than is often thought’ and that ‘the Mg2+ dose is a major factor controlling the amount of Mg2+ absorbed’. PubMed ›
- Healthy adults given 0–80 mEq magnesium with a meal: the fraction absorbed fell from 65% at the lowest intake to 11% at the highest (within-subject). A 100 mg (about 8 mEq) dose sits at the efficient end of that curve; the study gives no figure for citrate taken in water. PubMed ›
- The 1997 Dietary Reference Intakes report set the adult tolerable upper intake level for supplemental magnesium at 350 mg a day, with diarrhea the limiting factor (restated in a 2023 perspective, self-described as arguing the level is too low, in which seven studies at 128–1,200 mg/day found no significant difference in diarrhea from controls). This scoop is 29% of that ceiling. PubMed ›
- The FDA Daily Value for magnesium is 420 mg (fda.gov, ‘Daily Value on the Nutrition and Supplement Facts Labels’, 2024): 100 mg is 23.8%, matching the panel's 24% DV; the listing text's 50 mg would be 12% DV. The two label versions cannot both be right.
- From food alone, 48% of the US population consumed less than the required magnesium in 2005–2006, down from 56% in 2001–2002, per a review whose first author is at a magnesium-advocacy center. A 100 mg serving is a modest top-up against that gap, not repletion. PubMed ›
- Meta-analysis of 14 randomized trials (542 participants): no significant between-group improvement in strength, peak torque or power from magnesium supplementation in athletes and active people with relatively high magnesium status; possible benefit noted only in deficient groups. PubMed ›
- A review of 12 trials in athletes and active adults (116–500 mg/day, 1 day to 3 months) finds most show no effect of magnesium supplementation on strength, anaerobic or aerobic performance; magnesium status was rarely measured. The 100 mg here is below the lowest dose reviewed. PubMed ›
- A USDA review: supplementing physically active people with adequate magnesium status has not been shown to enhance performance; benefit is expected only where status is low. Hard training may raise the requirement by roughly 10–20%. PubMed ›
- 9 male recreational runners kept on a low-magnesium diet took 500 mg a day for 7 days before a downhill 10 km run (double-blind crossover): IL-6 and soreness fell versus placebo (within-subject), but time-trial performance and 24-hour muscle force showed no significant improvement. Five times this scoop's dose, in a deficiency setting. PubMed ›
- Whole-body sweat magnesium averaged 9.8 ± 4.8 mg/L in 8 trained athletes cycling 90 minutes in the heat (author at the Gatorade Sports Science Institute): 1–2 litres of sweat loses about 10–20 mg. The 100 mg ingested here is several times that, before allowing for incomplete absorption. PubMed ›
- Symptomatic hypermagnesemia is very rare in people with normal kidneys and usually iatrogenic; magnesium leaves the body through the kidneys, which is why the standard caution for impaired kidney function applies even at 100 mg. PubMed ›
At 100 mg, trimagnesium citrate is a soluble, well-absorbed form supplying about a quarter of the Daily Value, well under the 350 mg supplemental ceiling and more than a session's sweat loss. Pooled trials show no significant performance, strength or recovery benefit in magnesium-replete active adults. The 100 mg vs 50 mg label discrepancy must be settled against the tub.
6000 mg per scoop: L-Leucine 3000 mg · L-Isoleucine 1500 mg · L-Valine 1500 mgBCAA 2:1:1 Blend (Fermented, Instantized)
Leucine, isoleucine and valine are the three essential amino acids with a branched side chain. Here they are free-form L-amino acids at 3,000, 1,500 and 1,500 mg, a 2:1:1 ratio by weight. ‘Fermented’ means made by bacterial fermentation of plant sugars (Corynebacterium glutamicum or E. coli), the standard industrial route and a non-animal source. ‘Instantized’ is a manufacturers' term for powder processed to wet and disperse quickly in water; no peer-reviewed source specific to amino acids was found, so it is described here, not cited.
Why it is here: The listing's second bullet: ‘Full-spectrum essential amino acids (EAAs) with 8g EAAs, including 6g fermented instantized BCAAs (2:1:1), to support muscle recovery and lean muscle goals.*’
- An engineering review (no competing interests) cites a market report putting 2:1:1 products at 87.1% of the BCAA market and describes fermentation replacing chemical synthesis and protein hydrolysis as the economical route. 2:1:1 is documented as a market convention, not a tested optimum. PubMed ›
- The only direct ratio comparison found is in finishing pigs on protein-restricted diets (2:1:1 versus 2:1:2, on lipid metabolism; the authors recommended 2:1:2). No human trial comparing BCAA ratios on exercise or muscle outcomes was located. Animal data. PubMed ›
- 8 healthy children studied over 42 days by indicator amino-acid oxidation (no competing interests): leucine given without isoleucine and valine ‘limited total body protein synthesis’, and among the medical-formula ratios tested about 3:1:1 was best. The principle that the other two must accompany leucine is what a 2:1:1 blend satisfies. PubMed ›
- Microbial fermentation with Escherichia coli and Corynebacterium glutamicum is the major method for producing L-leucine (review). ‘Fermented’ on this label names the ordinary manufacturing route; no source shows fermentation-made amino acids act differently in the body from the same amino acids made any other way. PubMed ›
- Resistance-trained young men (10, crossover; GlaxoSmithKline-funded): 5.6 g BCAA alone after lifting raised myofibrillar protein synthesis 22% over placebo across 0–4 h, the closest dose match to this scoop, while the authors write BCAA alone ‘does not maximally stimulate’ synthesis because the other essential amino acids run short. PubMed ›
- A review (author with amino-acid industry ties) argues BCAAs taken alone cannot sustain muscle protein synthesis because the other essential amino acids become rate-limiting. This scoop's six other essential amino acids answer that argument, so any synthesis statement belongs to the whole mixture rather than to the BCAA fraction or its ratio. PubMed ›
- The International Society of Sports Nutrition's protein position stand: acute doses should carry 700–3,000 mg of leucine with a balanced array of the essential amino acids, and ‘it is the EAAs that are required to stimulate MPS’. This scoop's 3,000 mg leucine meets the figure. PubMed ›
- Meta-analysis of 8 studies (37 effects, 2007–2017): BCAA supplementation reduced delayed-onset muscle soreness after exercise training (effect size 0.73, 95% CI 0.50–0.96) — soreness, not performance. PubMed ›
- A systematic review of 11 BCAA-only studies (French public funding; no conflicts declared) finds the muscle-damage benefit confined to daily intakes above 200 mg per kg for more than 10 days, started at least 7 days before the damaging exercise. One scoop is about 75–86 mg/kg for a 70–80 kg adult (PearlQuant's arithmetic). PubMed ›
- 12 untrained young women took 100 mg/kg BCAA (about 7 g, roughly 2.3:1:1.2, a ratio close to this blend) or placebo before squats: the supplement suppressed the fall in muscle force, to about 80% of control, seen with placebo. The one ratio-matched human trial found; a small acute study. PubMed ›
- 5 healthy men took 77 mg/kg oral BCAA (about 5.4 g at 70 kg, close to this scoop) before 60 minutes of one-leg exercise: arterial BCAA doubled, muscle ammonia production rose (1,670 vs 1,112 µmol/kg, P<0.05, within-subject) and release of other essential amino acids fell, read as less protein breakdown. PubMed ›
- 9 well-trained cyclists rode three 100 km time trials with placebo, glucose, or glucose plus BCAA (crossover): finish times showed no significant difference (160.1, 157.2, 159.8 minutes), while plasma ammonia was significantly higher with BCAA (between-trial, P<0.05). PubMed ›
- 132 adults with overweight or obesity on a 24-week weight-loss programme took 0.1 g/kg/day BCAA (about 7 g, near this scoop), placebo or a high-protein diet: no significant between-group difference in insulin sensitivity or metabolic profile, and BCAA did not preserve lean mass. Funding not stated in the record. PubMed ›
- In 2,422 adults without diabetes followed 12 years (NIH-funded), higher fasting blood isoleucine, leucine and valine each predicted future type 2 diabetes (top versus lowest quartile). These are the body's own circulating levels in people not taking supplements; the study does not test whether a BCAA drink raises risk. PubMed ›
- A review (NIDDK-funded) presents the direction of causality between high circulating BCAA and insulin resistance as unresolved, including that insulin resistance may raise BCAA rather than the reverse; it gives no evidence for or against a 6 g intra-workout dose in healthy adults. PubMed ›
- Maple syrup urine disease, a rare inherited inability to break down BCAA, is managed by lifelong dietary BCAA restriction with close monitoring; a 6 g BCAA serving is incompatible with that diet (an inference from the restriction figures). PubMed ›
- A review of BCAA in health and disease advises strategies that ‘avoid adverse effects of BCAA on ammonia production in subjects with liver cirrhosis and urea cycle disorders’; BCAA are a studied therapy in cirrhosis, to be used under medical guidance rather than self-dosed from a sports product. PubMed ›
Six grams of 2:1:1 BCAA is a conventional, fermentation-made dose with no identified safety concern for healthy adults, and with the six other essential amino acids in the scoop it forms a complete mixture. Alone, BCAA at this dose give a modest, short-lived rise in muscle protein synthesis and, at larger multi-day doses, less soreness and a lower blood marker of muscle damage (creatine kinase) without faster recovery of strength; they have not been shown to build muscle or improve performance, and they measurably raise exercise ammonia.
3000 mg per scoop — the ‘2’ of the 2:1:1 blendL-Leucine (Instantized)
L-Leucine is the branched-chain essential amino acid most studied as the trigger of muscle protein synthesis, acting through the mTORC1 signalling pathway. Here it is 3,000 mg of free-form, fermentation-made leucine, half the blend and the largest single amino-acid amount on the panel.
Why it is here: The listing gives leucine the lead position and the largest amount in the blend; it makes no leucine-specific claim.
- In cultured human cells (NIH and HHMI funded), leucine binds the sensor protein Sestrin2, releasing GATOR2 and switching on mTORC1, the cell's growth signal; arginine did not. A mechanism in cells, not a human trial, and it says nothing about 3 g in a drink. PubMed ›
- Healthy young men at rest (grants: MRC and NIH): 3.42 g free leucine raised myofibrillar protein synthesis about 110% over the following hours against each man's fasted baseline (within-group). A short tracer surrogate with no exercise. PubMed ›
- 24 young men after one-leg resistance exercise (CIHR-funded): 6.25 g whey plus about 3 g leucine matched 25 g whey for protein synthesis at 1–3 h, but at 3–5 h only the full whey dose stayed elevated (184% vs 55%, between-group, P=0.036). A 3 g-leucine drink does not replace a protein meal. PubMed ›
- 40 young men after resistance exercise (double-blind): over 1.5–4.5 h, synthesis was greatest after 25 g whey (about 267%) and after a low-protein drink brought to 5.0 g total leucine (about 220%, P=0.002); the 3.0 g total-leucine arm did not reach that level. PubMed ›
- 20 untrained young adults eating adequate protein took 3.0 g leucine or placebo after each session for 8 weeks of resistance training (double-blind): muscle cross-sectional area rose 8.9% vs 9.6% and leg press 33% vs 37% (leucine vs placebo, P>0.05) — no significant added muscle or strength at exactly this label's dose. Small and underpowered. PubMed ›
- Meta-analysis of 9 randomized trials in older adults: leucine raised the muscle protein fractional synthetic rate versus control (SMD 1.08, 95% CI 0.50–1.67) but did not change lean body mass (SMD 0.18, 95% CI −0.18 to 0.54, P=0.32). Supports ‘stimulates synthesis’, not ‘builds muscle’, and only in the elderly. PubMed ›
- 5 healthy young men took leucine stepwise from 50 to 1,250 mg/kg/day over 29 study days (within-subject): plasma leucine and blood ammonia rose above 500 mg/kg/day, and the authors flag intakes over about 39 g/day as a possible risk. This scoop's 3 g (about 43 mg/kg) is near the lowest step. PubMed ›
Three grams of leucine acutely raises muscle protein synthesis for a few hours in tracer studies and is far below any proposed upper level. In untrained adults eating enough protein, the same 3 g after training added no significant muscle or strength over 8 weeks.
1500 mg per scoop — the first ‘1’ of the 2:1:1 blendL-Isoleucine (Instantized)
L-Isoleucine is an essential branched-chain amino acid, an isomer of leucine with the same formula and a different branch position. Here it is 1,500 mg of free-form, fermentation-made isoleucine, a quarter of the blend.
Why it is here: The listing includes it as the first ‘1’ of the 2:1:1 ratio and makes no isoleucine-specific claim. In the research literature its distinctive interest is glucose uptake into muscle.
- Rats given oral isoleucine (authors employed by Otsuka Pharmaceutical Factory): skeletal-muscle glucose uptake 73% greater than controls (between-group) and lower plasma glucose, while leucine did not; companion work used 0.3 g/kg, roughly 21 g for a 70 kg person, more than ten times this label's 1.5 g. Animal data. PubMed ›
- 12 healthy lean adults received isoleucine 5 g or 10 g or control into the stomach 15 minutes before a mixed-nutrient drink (randomized crossover): 10 g reduced the 60-minute glucose rise (P<0.01); 5 g showed no significant effect. This label's 1.5 g sits below the dose that was null. PubMed ›
- 15 healthy men received 10 g leucine, isoleucine, valine or control before a mixed drink (double-blind crossover; NHMRC-funded): isoleucine and leucine lowered peak glucose versus control and versus valine (P<0.05), partly by slowing stomach emptying. At rest, at 10 g, with no exercise endpoint. PubMed ›
- 8 trained men took placebo, leucine, BCAA or full EAA around resistance exercise (crossover): mTORC1 signaling ordered placebo < leucine < BCAA < EAA at 90 minutes, and 4E-BP1 phosphorylation with BCAA and EAA was 40% above leucine alone at 180 minutes (between-arm, P<0.05). Signaling, not measured protein synthesis; doses not in the abstract. PubMed ›
- In the children's indicator-oxidation study above, leucine without isoleucine and valine limited whole-body protein synthesis; isoleucine's documented role is as a companion to leucine rather than an independent effect at 1.5 g. PubMed ›
At 1.5 g, isoleucine's job in this scoop is to accompany leucine so the blend is not leucine alone. Human glucose-lowering effects appeared only at 10 g, not 5 g, and the muscle glucose-uptake data are from rats at far higher doses, so no independent effect is plausible at this amount.
1500 mg per scoop — the second ‘1’ of the 2:1:1 blendL-Valine (Instantized)
L-Valine is the third branched-chain essential amino acid, with the smallest side chain of the three. Here it is 1,500 mg of free-form, fermentation-made valine, a quarter of the blend.
Why it is here: The listing includes it to complete the 2:1:1 ratio and makes no valine-specific claim. The one mechanism specific to valine and isoleucine in sports formulas is competition with tryptophan for brain uptake, the ‘central fatigue’ idea.
- In the same 15-man crossover, 10 g valine before a mixed drink did not lower peak glucose (unlike 10 g leucine or isoleucine, P<0.05) and raised glucagon versus control — no independent metabolic benefit, even at nearly seven times this label's dose. PubMed ›
- 7 glycogen-lowered trained cyclists drank a BCAA solution or flavored water during 80 minutes of cycling (crossover): perceived exertion 7% lower and mental fatigue 15% lower with BCAA, and the rise in the free-tryptophan-to-BCAA ratio blunted, but maximal work in the final 20 minutes showed no significant difference. Dose not in the abstract. PubMed ›
- A review finds that drugs altering serotonin in humans failed to change exercise capacity and calls serotonin's role in central fatigue ‘often overrated’, pointing instead to dopamine and noradrenaline mainly in the heat. It examined drugs, not BCAA, and weakens the premise behind ‘valine fights fatigue’. PubMed ›
- In the 100 km cycling crossover above, adding BCAA to glucose did not change finish time but raised plasma ammonia; valine shares in that ammonia load without buying endurance performance. PubMed ›
- No tolerable upper intake level has been established for valine or isoleucine, and no national agency has adopted any amino-acid upper level; a 2023 review states that long-term effects of single amino-acid supplements in humans remain unknown. 1.5 g is a modest dose by any standard reviewed. PubMed ›
At 1.5 g, valine completes the 2:1:1 ratio and otherwise has no demonstrated independent effect: the one human valine-alone trial found no glucose benefit at 10 g, and BCAA drinks lowered perceived effort without changing performance.
Citrate here; chelate, glycinate, taurate, malate, lactate, chloride, threonate, orotate elsewhereMagnesium forms: what the trials say
Magnesium is always sold bound to something: an organic acid (citrate, malate, lactate, orotate, threonate), an amino acid (glycinate/bisglycinate, taurate) or an inorganic partner (oxide, chloride). A chelate is a metal ion held by a ligand that binds through two or more atoms at once, closing a ring; bisglycinate meets that definition, trimagnesium citrate is classed as an organic salt, and taurine's sulfonate is a weak binder, so 'magnesium taurate' is better described as a salt or complex. Approximate magnesium by weight: oxide 60%, citrate 16%, bisglycinate 14%, taurate 9%, orotate 6.6% (formula weights, not a cited trial).
Why it is here: Walker 2003 is the one trial on this page with an amino-acid chelate arm; this card sets out what it showed for the chelate and what the evidence says for the other magnesium forms, including the magnesium taurate PearlQuant also reviews.
- Walker 2003 (46 analysed of 51 enrolled; 300 mg magnesium a day for 60 days as amino-acid chelate, citrate, oxide or placebo): the abstract reports the chelate only pooled with citrate as ‘the organic forms’, which had greater 24-hour urinary magnesium than oxide at 60 days (P=0.033). It gives no chelate-versus-citrate contrast on any endpoint; citrate alone was greatest on serum magnesium (P=0.026 after one dose, P=0.006 at 60 days) and on saliva at 60 days; red-cell magnesium showed no differences; oxide did not differ from placebo. The amino acid is not named. PubMed ›
- A 2025 systematic review's extraction of Walker's full text (part-funded by K+S, a mineral-salt producer) adds that urinary magnesium showed no significant treatment differences acutely or chronically before outlier adjustment, that the 60-day organic-versus-oxide difference is reported after that adjustment against two placebos (cellulose and sorbitol), and that citrate was the only arm with a significant serum rise from its own baseline (0.68 to 0.73 mmol/L). PubMed ›
- An independent review (authors declare no conflict) tabulates Walker's analysed intakes as 269 mg a day of magnesium in the chelate arm, 255 in citrate and 280 in oxide, with no dietary control; its only summary is that citrate and chelate were both better absorbed than oxide, with no ranking between the two. Its conclusion across trials: ‘The type of Mg2+ salt appears less relevant than is often thought.’ PubMed ›
- Magnesium diglycinate, a true bisglycinate chelate, against oxide in 12 ileal-resection patients (NIH/FDA-funded; single 100 mg dose, stable-isotope crossover): absorption ‘not different for the two supplements (23.5% vs 22.8% for magnesium chelate and MgO)’; the chelate did better only in the four worst oxide absorbers (23.5% vs 11.8%). Not healthy adults. PubMed ›
- Single-dose crossover in healthy adults (350 mg as bisglycinate, citrate, oxide or a trademarked ‘sucrosomial’ product; funding not stated): the only significant results favoured the trademarked product, including over bisglycinate in red cells. No bisglycinate advantage over citrate or oxide was found. PubMed ›
- Systematic review of 14 human studies (no competing interests): ‘Inorganic formulations appear to be less bioavailable than organic ones, and the percentage of absorption is dose dependent’; all magnesium supplements maintain physiological levels in healthy people without a prior deficit; it names no single form as better than the others. PubMed ›
- Chloride, lactate and aspartate in healthy volunteers at about 255 mg a day: ‘significantly higher and equivalent bioavailability’ to one another, all above oxide (4% fractional absorption). A soluble inorganic salt matched the organic ones, so solubility, not the ligand, explains the differences. PubMed ›
- 18 healthy women taking 365–500 mg a day as citrate/lactate tablets, hydroxide or chloride solution: ‘There was no statistical difference in urine elimination after intake of the different preparations.’ PubMed ›
- Animal data: 80 magnesium-depleted rats given ten salts with a tracer absorbed 50–67% from every salt; ‘the organic pidolate, citrate, gluconate and aspartate salts resulted in higher urinary 26Mg excretion than with inorganic salts’, though only slightly. Malate, gluconate and pidolate have no healthy-adult head-to-head trial. PubMed ›
- Animal data, and the source behind the ‘hourly bioavailability timeline’ charts that supplement brands publish: a single-dose rat study (Sprague Dawley, 400 mg per 70 kg) of sulfate, oxide, acetyl taurate, citrate and malate found ‘the area under the curve calculation is highest in the magnesium malate’, acetyl taurate second and fastest, with the highest brain level, and oxide and citrate lowest. The taurine compound tested is magnesium ACETYL taurate, a different molecule from magnesium taurate; no human timeline exists for either, and the rat ranking of citrate contradicts the human trials above. PubMed ›
- Magnesium taurate, the only human study found: adults with raised blood pressure (121 enrolled, 110 analysed) took a taurate–potassium citrate combination (121 mg magnesium plus 180 mg potassium a day) for 3 months with lifestyle counselling; ambulatory pressure fell about 11/8 mmHg and serum magnesium rose 0.1 mg/dL (within-group). Single-arm, no placebo, no comparator form, and a combination product, so nothing is attributable to the taurate form; the authors write that ‘causal inference was limited, underscoring the need for randomized trials’. PubMed ›
- The heart story for magnesium taurate traces to a 1996 hypothesis paper proposing the complex ‘may thus have considerable potential as a vascular-protective nutritional supplement’; it tested nothing and generated no data. PubMed ›
- Animal data: cadmium-poisoned rats (6 per group) given 2–4 mg/kg a day of magnesium taurate, the Cardiovascular Research product, for two weeks had restored blood pressure and heart antioxidant measures versus poisoned controls (no external funding); no absorption endpoint, no human arm. PubMed ›
- Magnesium L-threonate (Magtein): 44 older adults with cognitive impairment, 12 weeks, funded and authored by the developer: urinary magnesium excretion rose relative to placebo (p=0.027, from the full text), plasma magnesium was higher only at week 6, and a composite cognitive score improved versus placebo. No other magnesium form was compared. PubMed ›
- Animal data: the ‘raises brain magnesium’ claim for L-threonate comes from a rat study by the compound's developer (NIH-funded); no human brain or spinal-fluid magnesium measurement exists for the compound. PubMed ›
- Magnesium orotate: 79 severe heart-failure patients took 6 then 3 g of the salt a day for about a year (double-blind, placebo): survival 75.7% versus 51.6% (p<0.05). A pharmaceutical-dose cardiac adjunct with no absorption endpoint, published as a letter with an erratum; not relevant to 100 mg supplement doses. PubMed ›
- What a chelate is, from a chemistry paper funded by Balchem (owner of the chelate maker Albion; in vitro): a glycine peptide forms ‘a 6-coordinate octahedral magnesium complex via tetradentate HG3’, a ring around the metal. Whether a given powder is that structure or a blend of a magnesium salt with glycine is a manufacturing question no human trial here tested. PubMed ›
- The only regulator-style definition of ‘metal amino acid chelate’ is AAFCO's for animal feed: ‘the product resulting from the reaction of a metal ion from a soluble metal salt with amino acids with a mole ratio of 1 mole of metal to 1 to 3 (preferably 2) moles of amino acids’ (reproduced by two Alltech employees). It governs feed, not human supplements. PubMed ›
- ‘Fully reacted’, as in the Cardiovascular Research Magnesium Taurate listing's ‘a fully reacted complex and not simply a blend of the two materials’, has no definition in US food or supplement regulation: a full-text search of the eCFR on 2026-10-06 finds the phrase only in EPA polymer rules (40 CFR 721), never in Title 21. Manufacturer wording.
What separates magnesium forms in healthy adults appears to be mainly whether the salt dissolves, not which ligand is attached: chloride, lactate, aspartate and citrate all out-absorbed oxide and were not separated from one another on urinary excretion; in Walker's trial an amino-acid chelate, reported together with citrate, also out-absorbed oxide, though citrate alone gave the highest serum magnesium (red-cell magnesium did not differ). The healthy-adult comparisons cited here used 250–500 mg a day, so any difference at 100 mg is extrapolated. No trial found puts glycinate ahead of citrate; taurate has no human study comparing its absorption with other forms; threonate has a small developer-funded trial and orotate a small heart-failure trial, neither comparing forms. Plasma magnesium is tightly regulated and the kidney excretes the excess in replete people, so higher absorption is usually followed by higher urinary excretion.
Sources and caveats
Every paper item carries its PubMed id; the chemistry and Daily Value figures come from PubChem (CID 6099959) and fda.gov and have none. Points resting on animal or cell data are labelled (pigs for the ratio comparison, rats for isoleucine and glucose uptake, cultured cells for the leucine sensor). Industry or advocacy ties are stated inside the items where the paper states them. Dose transfer is stated honestly: the magnesium absorption trials used three to six times this scoop's dose, and the isoleucine and valine human trials used 5–10 g against 1.5 g on this label.
What the evidence says
- Healthy adults at rest (6 young, 7 elderly; NIH-funded; no placebo arm): a single 15 g dose of the nine essential amino acids raised muscle protein synthesis by about 0.04%/h in each age group, before versus after. That is nearly twice the 8 g in one scoop of this product. PubMed ›
- Healthy young men at rest (7, tracer study, no placebo): a single 3.42 g dose of free leucine roughly doubled muscle protein synthesis over the following hours against each man's own fasted baseline. One scoop carries 3,000 mg leucine. PubMed ›
- Resistance-trained young men (10, crossover; GlaxoSmithKline-funded): 5.6 g BCAA alone right after lifting raised myofibrillar protein synthesis 22% over placebo across 0–4 h (0.110 vs 0.090 %/h). The authors write that BCAA alone ‘does not maximally stimulate’ synthesis because the other essential amino acids run short; this product adds 2,000 mg of those six. PubMed ›
- A review (author holds shares in an essential-amino-acid company) concludes that the claim that BCAAs on their own stimulate muscle protein synthesis in people is ‘unwarranted’, because the other essential amino acids must then come from muscle protein breakdown; that is the case for complete mixes over BCAA-only products. This product supplies all nine, 75% of them BCAA. PubMed ›
- The International Society of Sports Nutrition's 2023 position stand on essential amino acids (several authors hold EAA-formulation patents and industry roles): at rest, synthesis is stimulated by 1.5–3.0 g doses and seems to plateau around 15–18 g; in interval training, 3.6 g EAA before exercise, or twice daily for 4–8 weeks, had no effect on time to exhaustion or workload progression. The stand makes no performance claim for intra-workout EAA. PubMed ›
- The same society's 2017 protein stand (no funding; several authors advise protein companies) advises that an acute protein dose carry 700–3,000 mg of leucine with a balanced array of the essential amino acids. This scoop's 3,000 mg leucine meets that figure; the six non-BCAA amino acids total 2,000 mg. PubMed ›
- Meta-analysis of 25 studies (479 participants, mean age 24; BCAA versus placebo at varied doses): small-to-moderate reductions in creatine kinase at 48 h (SMD −0.41) and in soreness at 24–48 h, with a dose–response relationship, but no significant faster recovery of muscle performance (SMD 0.08–0.21). Creatine kinase is an enzyme that leaks from damaged muscle fibres into the blood; a lower reading is read as less damage, but here the marker moved and the function did not. PubMed ›
- Meta-analysis of 8 trials (healthy adults after damaging exercise): BCAA versus placebo lowered the damage marker creatine kinase by about 72 U/L within 24 h and 145 U/L at 24 h, while muscle soreness did not differ significantly from placebo at any time point. PubMed ›
- A review of creatine kinase in exercise: its appearance in blood ‘has been generally considered to be an indirect marker of muscle damage’, yet ‘there is controversy in the literature concerning its validity in reflecting muscle damage as a consequence of level and intensity of physical exercise’, and ethnicity, age and sex shift the readings. A lower value is better only in the narrow sense that less enzyme left the muscle; the strength and performance data above are the test of recovery. PubMed ›
- A systematic review of 11 BCAA-only studies (French public funding; no conflicts declared) concludes that limiting muscle damage takes daily intakes above 200 mg per kg of body weight for more than 10 days, starting at least 7 days before the damaging exercise. One scoop's 6,000 mg BCAA is about 75–86 mg/kg for a 70–80 kg adult (PearlQuant's arithmetic). PubMed ›
- Recreationally active young men (36, three arms; supplements and funding from Optimal Labs; an author advises a supplement company): 10 g of essential amino acids before and after eccentric calf exercise (20 g that day, 2.5 times one scoop's EAA) and daily through 72 h lowered worst-pain soreness versus placebo at 24 h only (31.4 vs 64.6 on a 0–100 scale) and let calf swelling return to baseline by 72 h; no strength or creatine kinase endpoints. PubMed ›
- Review pooling sweat tests from 506 athletes (author employed by the Gatorade Sports Science Institute, PepsiCo): whole-body sweat sodium typically runs 10–70 mmol/L at 0.5–2 L/h, roughly 115–3,200 mg sodium an hour. One scoop supplies 100 mg sodium, about 11% of an hour's loss for an athlete sweating 1 L/h at 40 mmol/L (PearlQuant's arithmetic from the label, not the paper's). PubMed ›
- The American College of Sports Medicine's position stand on fluid replacement says electrolyte- and carbohydrate-containing drinks ‘can provide benefits over water alone under certain circumstances’ and recommends customized fluid replacement, because sweat rates and sweat electrolytes vary so much between people. This drink supplies 3 g of carbohydrate and 10 calories per scoop. PubMed ›
- Exercise-trained men (12, crossover; funded by Vita Coco): after a treadmill bout that cost about 2% of body mass, roughly 2.2 L of coconut water, coconut water from concentrate, a sports drink or bottled water rehydrated equally on fluid retention, plasma osmolality and a later run to exhaustion. One scoop contains 500 mg of coconut water powder. PubMed ›
- Systematic review for first-aid guidelines (11 studies, 3 on coconut water; very low certainty evidence): fresh coconut water drunk after exercise rehydrated no better than plain water on volume and hydration measures. PubMed ›
- Endurance-trained men (10, double-blind crossover): BCAA at 6 or 18 g/L added to a 6% sucrose drink during cycling at 70–75% of maximum raised blood BCAA but gave no significant difference in time to exhaustion (122 ± 3 min across drinks). No trial was found of an 8 g carbohydrate-free amino-acid drink on same-session resistance-training performance. PubMed ›
- Well-trained cyclists (9, crossover): glucose plus BCAA drunk during a 100 km ride was no faster than glucose alone or placebo (160 vs 157 vs 160 min). PubMed ›
- Highly trained cyclists (6, double-blind crossover): seven days of 1.8 g of a pantethine/pantothenic acid compound (about 0.8 g pantothenic acid, 8 times this scoop's 100 mg) plus allithiamin gave no significant difference from placebo in heart rate, lactate, gas exchange or 2,000 m time-trial time (178.2 vs 170.7 s, P = 0.58). No trial supports a training purpose for the 100 mg here, which is 2000% of the Daily Value. PubMed ›
- A 2023 review for the Nordic nutrition recommendations (no industry funding): no upper intake level has been set for pantothenic acid; clinical doses up to 2 g a day have not shown a health risk, and water retention and occasional diarrhoea are reported only at 10–20 g a day. PubMed ›
- Sucralose and acesulfame potassium are FDA-permitted sweeteners with acceptable daily intakes of 5 and 15 mg per kg of body weight (a 2026 review with no external funding). The listing does not say how much of either this product contains, so intake against those limits cannot be computed. PubMed ›
- Healthy adults (120, randomized; senior authors have ties to personalized-nutrition companies): two weeks of sucralose or saccharin sachets below the acceptable daily intake ‘significantly impaired glycemic responses’ as a group, with effects that were person-specific and microbiome-dependent; acesulfame potassium was not tested. A caveat on the sweetener, not a test of this product. PubMed ›
- Healthy lean young women (42, randomized, 4 weeks): daily water sweetened with sucralose, saccharin, or aspartame plus acesulfame potassium left glucose handling, insulin sensitivity, GLP-1 and body weight no different from plain water; a separate 14-day crossover in 17 adults found 136 mg sucralose a day left gut microbiota composition unchanged. PubMed ›
- Runners (16, randomized crossover; NIH grant record): rinsing the mouth with sucrose shortened a 12.8 km time trial versus water (1:03:47 vs 1:06:56), while sucralose rinses did not differ from water. Sweetness without energy gave no performance effect; acesulfame potassium was not tested. PubMed ›
- A review of human dose-response studies (author has advised an amino-acid industry council): proposed upper limits of 35 g a day for leucine in young adults and 4.5 g for tryptophan, and no-adverse-effect levels of 6 g for lysine and 3.2 g for methionine. One scoop is far below each; no human limit exists for isoleucine, valine or threonine, which make up 4,000 mg of the scoop. PubMed ›
- Coconut was added to the FDA's tree-nut list in 2006; in a single-centre analysis of 298 coconut IgE tests, sensitization correlated strongly only with macadamia and almond. The listing's ‘Contains: Tree Nuts (coconut)’ line follows that older list; the FDA's January 2025 allergen guidance no longer counts coconut as a tree nut. Anyone with a diagnosed coconut allergy should avoid it regardless. PubMed ›
No published trial of SILO[9], Hosstile or this formula was found in PubMed or ClinicalTrials.gov (searched 2026-10-05): the listing's ‘Clinically Dosed’ refers to ingredient amounts drawn from the literature, not to testing of this product. Summaries are PearlQuant's reading of each paper's full text or, where we do not hold it, its abstract; follow the PubMed links for the originals. Industry ties are noted where a paper states them. Sweat-sodium and coconut-water comparisons are PearlQuant's arithmetic from the label against published ranges, not results the papers report.
